Showing posts with label Science and Society. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Science and Society. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

If Darwin Had A Web Browser, He Would Never Have Written The Origin



I've got a post on Darwin and the pace of science today up at Scientific Blogging:

How can today's wired, multitasking scientist ever compete with the great scientists of the past? One feature of Darwin's work as a scientists was that it proceeded slowly, very, very slowly. He wrote massive groundbreaking books, compiled huge amounts of data on orchids, barnacles, and Galapagos animals, but all over a long period of time. Scientists in Darwin's day had hours to kill on long voyages, took long walks out in the field, and waited while their scientific correspondence leisurely wended its way across oceans or continents.

Even in the first half of the 20th century, great scientists are famous for what they accomplished on long walks, hiking trips, and train rides. Niels Bohr would walk for hours around Copenhagen and come up with groundbreaking ideas, while Werner Heisenberg spent weeks every year hiking in the mountains. Even Richard Feynman, working in our more modern (but still pre-internet) era, insisted on long blocks of time to concentrate; he likened his thought process to building a house of cards, easily toppled by distraction and difficult to put back together.

Does that mean the kind of science we do in our overscheduled, multitasking world will never be the same as it was in the past? Certainly in one sense it won't - earlier generations of scientists had one distinct advantage we don't have today: Servant

Read the rest here

A note to regular readers: I'm going to start a division of labor between my blogs - posts aimed at a broad, non-specialist audience will go up at my column on Scientific Blogging, and more technical stuff or personal rants (which I haven't written much of lately, but more on systems biology and genomics is coming) will stay here in their entirety. I'll put links and the first couple paragraphs of my Scientific Blogging posts here.

Saturday, January 12, 2008

An "Irrational Attachment to The Theory of Evolution"?

In Gail Collins' NY Times column today, she says this:

Huckabee seems to be a nice guy, but conservatives are afraid he’d break up the old evangelical-plutocrat Republican alliance and most liberals are restrained by their irrational attachment to the theory of evolution.

Excuse me? I can't quite tell if Collins is being tongue-in-cheek (I frankly don't read her column enough to get where she's coming from), but it looks like Collins is the rationally challenged one here. What she just said is just as absurd as something like: "most liberals are restrained by their irrational attachment to the theory of quantum mechanics."

For people like myself who prefer to reside in the reality-based community, acceptance of the evidence for evolution is in fact an excellent litmus test for people who want my vote. It's a good indication of how decision-makers value evidence versus pet beliefs. Scientific evidence does not necessarily dictate what the correct government policy should be, but it sure as hell can rule out harebrained ones. I view that as a good thing.

This post isn't an endoresement or a slam against any particular political party or candidate - except of course candidates who have an irrational opposition to very successful, fundamental fields of science. The point is, creation vs. evolution isn't just some freak side issue on the fringes of the culture wars - it cuts to the heart of how people respond to the single most successful approach humans have developed for understanding and influencing the reality-based world.

Friday, January 04, 2008

A Science Debate in the US Presidential Election?

It's a long shot, but a worthwhile cause. If you care about science issues in the upcoming US election, consider signing up to support Science Debate 2008.

Tuesday, December 04, 2007

Stem Cell Researchers Respond to Bush's Claim

The White House has claimed that Bush's firm stance against embryonic stem cell research helped to stimulate the recent breakthroughs in creating pluripotent cells without destroying embryos.

In an editorial in the Washington Post, stem cell researchers themselves respond.

Monday, November 19, 2007

Monkey Stem Cells From Cloned Embryos - Humans Are Next...

Headlines last week reported that researchers successfully produced stem cells from cloned monkey embryos. Using a process that has become almost routine with mice, scientists can now make make primate embryonic stem cells that are genetically identical to a given DNA donor. Once we learn to do this in humans, the possibility of stem cell based treatments for heart disease, neurodegeneration, and more will be closer to reality. But in the US and elsewhere, can we develop the political will to let this research move forward?

In case you missed the headlines, the story is this: a group of researchers at the Oregon Health and Science University led by Dr. Shoukhrat Mitalipov used the process of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) to create cloned Rhesus macaque embryonic stem cells. SCNT involves taking the DNA from an adult skin cell and implanting this DNA into an egg cell from which the DNA has been removed. This DNA transplant procedure can produce an embryo without the need for a fertilized egg - and most importantly, it produces an embryo genetically identical the DNA donor, which means that potential therapies using SCNT-derived stem cells wouldn't be rejected by a patient's immune system.

SCNT itself is old news; what is impressive in this research is the new ability to do SCNT with primate cells. This breakthrough was enabled by better imaging technology. SCNT is like a heart transplant where you just rip out the old heart with a giant tug, leaving a lot of damage behind. With the new technology, Dr. Mitalipov's team was able to better see what they were doing as they carried out the procedure.

If it can be done in monkeys, it's just a matter of time before it can be done in humans. Back in 2004 the world thought that human stem cells had been created from such cloned embryos, but that research turned out to be faked. The researcher behind those studies, Woo Suk Hwang from Seoul National University, was exposed as a crook and the already controversial image of human stem cell research was tarnished. Because of this history, Nature and Dr. Mitalipov went to great lengths to prove that the macaque embryonic stem cells reported in this paper are real, including requesting genetic confirmation from an independent group.

Where does this research go from here? Scientifically, we're still some way off from using these cells to replace ailing nerve or heart tissue in patients with terminal diseases. The many political and legal hurdles are even more formidable in the immediate future. To take just one example, at SCNT's current success rates you need hundreds of eggs from donors before you get just one successful embryo. Egg donation is not a pleasant process, and laws in some states prevent researchers from financially compensating donors, unlike other types of research volunteers who are paid for their time and trouble. Success rates will no doubt improve as researchers learn important tweaks in the procedure, but that can't be done without lots of trying. If the US doesn't develop the political will to make it possible for stem cell researchers to do their work, future treatments will be developed elsewhere and the US will lack the expertise in both research and patient treatment. The macaque stem cell paper indicates that the day when we will know how to use embryonic stem cells for medical treatments looms ahead, and unless we make changes in this country, we won't benefit from them.

Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Intelligent Design's Day in Court on NOVA

Last night the PBS series NOVA featured a two-hour show on the 2005 Dover, PA Intelligent Design trial. If you missed it, go check out clips and some great evolution resources at the show's website. As a creation/evolution junkie, I had previously read all of the trial transcripts, but reading transcripts was no substitute for seeing and hearing the major participants on camera. And while the big players from the Discovery Institute refused to be interviewed, NOVA managed to get just about everyone else on camera, including one of the defense's expert witnesses and the two ex-school board members who started the whole mess. These guys made it abundantly clear in their own words that intelligent design in Dover was not about improving science education - it was all about pushing creationism among the students.

The show was generally well done, in spite of some badly acted (not to mention tacky) courtroom reenactments. There were excellently illustrated segments discussing science's success in some areas where intelligent design advocates have claimed there are problems, such as transitional fossils and the bacterial flagellum. I was happy to see that the show also spent time discussing how the development of genetics, and much later, genomics, were big tests of evolution. Darwin's ideas enabled scientists to make predictions that were borne out decades later in scientific fields that Darwin knew nothing about.

The most entertaining part of the show were the interviews with the two ex-school board members (who were caught lying during the trial) and a local Dover pastor. The founders of intelligent design have gone to great lengths to paint their ideas as serious science, not creationism. And yet on the show we hear Dover's local intelligent design advocates explain that they pushed intelligent design in school because they were concerned that the malleable students of Dover were having their good Christian faith weakened by evolution - not because the board members cared (or knew anything about) a good science education. Alan Bonsell and Bill Buckingham made it repeatedly clear that their main beef with evolution is that it offends their religious beliefs.

Judge John Jones, who presided over the trial, made a sobering statement towards the end of the show. He said that before this case he would have never have imagined that he would receive threats after an Establishment Clause case. Jones and his family were placed under the protection of the US Marshals for a time after his ruling, due to threats of physical harm Jones received. Of course I'm biased, but I can't imagine that Jones would have received such threats had he ruled the other way. And while I have no doubt that the overwhelming majority of creationists would never, ever make such threats, much less act on them, the incident does expose the hatred that some people feel towards those who work to keep our science curricula untainted by religious dogma. This was a nasty episode in creation/evolution history, but with luck this trial will produce a lull in the battle for a couple of years. Unfortunately, we all know that this controversy is not over.

Monday, October 01, 2007

Do Universities care about more than image?

"What makes the modern university different from any other corporation?" That's the question asked in the NY Times this week. In light of increasingly unaffordable tuition rates and the profitable but corrupt business of lending huge sums of money to students, do universities deserve their nonprofit status? Is the tight competition for federal grants corrupting the mission of universities?

The Times isn't so sure:

"Driven by big science and global competition, our top universities compete for “market share” and “brand-name positioning,” employ teams of consultants and lobbyists and furnish their campuses with luxuries in order to attract paying “customers” — a word increasingly used as a synonym for students."

I can relate: during my orientation as a new postdoc at Washington University, I was given what basically amounted to a marketing lecture by the HR person: I was told about the ongoing marketing campaign to raise awareness around town about our medical school's national status, and lectured about how every day in my work I should think about how I can please my customers. And just who are my customers? Everyone - my mentor, the grad students in the lab, the dean, and God knows who else.

So ok, my job orientation indoctrination was a dumb triviality, but are big research univeristies still pursuing the higher mission they were founded on? I think that the answer to a large degree is still yes, but the risk that money concerns are overwhelming more fundamental ones is real. Not all, but most cutting edge scientific research these days requires a lot of money and supportive infrastructure. That also means a lot of 'overhead' funds for the universities that win lots of federal dollars.

Most disturbing is the excessive focus on the university's image, rather than substance, because a good image (including a good US News ranking), as coporate America knows, can often be more effective at attracting customers than a truly substantial product.

Major research universities are a good thing - they produce the best science in the world, and often the best medical care in the world. But they (along with great liberal arts schools) should also produce a top education for their students, who will hopefully in the future produce more great science and medical care. Students who are educated in an environment of excessive concern about image and coddling 'customers' are unlikely to make great future scholars.

The biggest casualty of this trend, beside the decline in the general quality of a college education, and collegetown streets draped with tacky banners emblazoned with slogans pushing the local school's image, is the eroding status of universities as the best source in our society of excellent, honest scholarship. If we don't pass on how and why we do good scholarship, our culture will forget and be surpassed by others that do care about honestly understanding our world.

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

Domesticating Biotechnology in the 21st Century

Will we domesticate biotechnology in the next 50 years? More than 150 years of spectacular advances in physics, chemistry, and computing have thoroughly transformed the way we live. Yet so far, the big revolutions in molecular biology have had their impact primarily on professional laboratories, not our everyday lives. What do we need to do in order to domesticate biotech?

Physicist Freeman Dyson recently explored this question:

"Will the domestication of high technology, which we have seen marching from triumph to triumph with the advent of personal computers and GPS receivers and digital cameras, soon be extended from physical technology to biotechnology?"

Dyson predicts this will happen in the next 50 years:

"I predict that the domestication of biotechnology will dominate our lives during the next fifty years at least as much as the domestication of computers has dominated our lives during the previous fifty years."

What form might this domestication take? Among Dyson's suggestions for domestication is user-friendly genetic engineering for hobbyist plant and animal breeders. I'm not so sure that making genetic engineering idiot-proof is the major hurdle; in fact, genetic engineering today is somewhat of an oxymoron. We may be able to engineer pet fish to express a green fluorescent protein, but we honestly have no clue how to engineer any but the most simple, monogenic traits.

We will dometicate biotechnology, and I predict that this will happen in two ways: by bringing biotech into the day-to-day practice of medicine, and by bringing genetic engineering to a truly sophisticated level, on par with aerospace engineering.

Bringing Biotech into the Clinic
To be honest, with the exception of imaging technology, medicine as practiced today is extremely low-tech. Very few of the fancy techniques that scientists use in a molecular biology lab are available on a routine, affordable basis in the clinic. Blood tests are downright primitive. And in spite of all of our sophisticated genome analysis technology, detailed genotyping is almost never used in medicine. Biotech is ripe for domestication in the clinic.

Dirt Cheap Genome Sequencing
One day, every newborn child will be routinely genotyped; that is, the hospital lab will take a blood sample and, quickly and cheaply, determine that baby's DNA sequence in the millions of places where humans can differ. Our genotype will become part of our medical records, which of course we ourselves will also have access to. Genotyping can be used to customize drug and disease treatments, as well as suggest lifestyle choices that will help avoid or minimize diseases that a person may be susceptible to. Universal genotyping can even be used by family history hobbyists.

The technological barriers will soon be overcome, leaving the social ones remaining as the largest obstacle to universal genotyping. Who can have access to this information? How much do you really want to know about your disease susceptibility? Your paternity? These aren't trivial questions.

The Universal Blood Test
High-tech, preventative diagnostics will transform the way we practice medicine. Most of today's diagnostic tests, with the exception of medical imaging, are based on decades-old techniques. Leroy Hood, a founder of Seattle's Institute for Systems Biology is working on technology for affordable, routine blood tests that will provide a comprehensive picture of your health, including the very early detection of diseases like cancer. These blood tests, one day cheap enough to be done annually, could thoroughly modernize preventative medicine.

Real Genetic Engineering
At Boeing, engineers can essentially design a new plane completely by computer, and predict in minute detail how that plane will behave in real-world weather. True genetic engineering will mean being able to make such quantitative predictions with the cell, but currently our abilities to make quantitative predictions are embarrassingly small. Analogous to Boeing's computer-aided design, computer aided genetic engineering will one day enable us to develop gene replacement therapies that don't have cancer as a side effect, develop specific, side effect-free drugs that treat tough diseases, and develop microbes that can generate energy from renewable resources, clean up toxic spills, or perform chemical reactions that organic chemists haven't yet been able to achieve.

The first step towards achieving this level of sophistication will be to completely understand all of the parts of an organism; the next will be to understand how those parts work as a system. We've nearly reached that first step for a eukaryotic organism: brewer's yeast, one of biology's key model organisms, will have an essentially completely annotated parts list within the next 10 years or so. Many scientists are now struggling with the next step, trying to make sense of how these parts work as a system. Yeast will be the first Boeing 747 of biology - an organism that we can completely and predictively model by computer, without extensive trial and error studies in the lab.

Maybe, after we've really learned how to do genetic engineering, hobbyists will then fulfill Dyson's dream of user-friendly plant design, and come up with a way to make glow-in-the-dark roses.

Sunday, August 19, 2007

The Politics of God in the NY Times Magazine

The NY Times Magazine today has cover piece arguing that while the West may have figured out how to largely separate politics and religion, the rest of the world is unlikely to follow:

"Countless millions still pursue the age-old quest to bring the whole of human life under God’s authority, and they have their reasons."

If that's really true, we can expect that modern science will be a phenomenon largely confined to the West, with the rest of the world using science, pioneered elsewhere, to build more hi-tech weapons.

Perhaps though, the case is overstated in the NY Times piece - Japan and Korea have relatively secular politics, and a correspondingly strong scientific infrastructure. Several modernizing nations, such as India and China, are working hard to build their scientific reputations; to do so requires some commitment by their respective goverments to separate ideology from the political decision making process. The young Chinese and Indian graduate students, coming in droves to the US for a scientific education, will inevitably make life better in their non-Western home countries when they return.

The next step is to figure out how to get young Iraqis, Jordanians, Iranians, and Africans to come seeking a scientific education in the US.

Sunday, May 20, 2007

It's not just the pet food...

Why is the US so driven by greed? Somehow we care so much about corporate profits that we can't even effectively make sure that our food is safe. This story in Sunday's Washington Post (free registration required) details the tainted food (human food - not just pet food) shipments from China that the underfunded and understaffed FDA is trying to keep out of the US food supply. The foods that the FDA turns back are unsanitary, stored in carcinogenic preservatives, filled with antibiotics banned in the US, and much more.

In spite of numerous recommendations from the National Academy of Sciences and various other expert panels to institute more serious efforts to protect our food supply, corporate interests and the large potential Chinese market for US exporters have been higher priorities than the safety of US consumers.

Here's how the Washington Post puts it:

"Dead pets and melamine-tainted food notwithstanding, change will prove difficult, policy experts say, in large part because U.S. companies have become so dependent on the Chinese economy that tighter rules on imports stand to harm the U.S. economy, too.

"'So many U.S. companies are directly or indirectly involved in China now, the commercial interest of the United States these days has become to allow imports to come in as quickly and smoothly as possible,' said Robert B. Cassidy, a former assistant U.S. trade representative for China and now director of international trade and services for Kelley Drye Collier Shannon, a Washington law firm."

The US economy always ends up being the sacred cow that must not be harmed at any cost - such as our health or our environment. And it is unfortunate that in a nation where much of the world's very best science is done, and where at one time we made groundbreaking advances in modern society by establishing agencies that were charged with protecting our citizens based on the best science available, we can't put together the political will to actually make use of our considerable expertise to keep our food safe.

Thursday, May 10, 2007

A Bad Mix: Psychiatric Drugs, Money, and Children

I gripe about the poverty of postdoctoral scientists, but I'd rather be poor and keep my professional integrity than be lavishly paid by drug makers and lose my conscience. The NY Times has a story about psychiatrists who receive payments from drug makers, and who also just happen to have a tendency to frequently prescribe 'atypical drugs' for children. (Atypical here means prescribed for an unconventional use or patient population, one for which the drug was not initially designed. Atypical prescriptions are not necessarily bad - physicians are allowed to use their professional judgment to write such prescriptions.) This isn't a new issue by any means, but the NY Times story reemphasizes its importance.

The story described physicians who are paid thousands of dollars by drug makers to lecture on or write about (in other words, promote) potentially best-selling anti-psychotic drugs. Those same physicians just happen to prescribe these drugs much, much more frequently than physicians who are not paid by pharmaceutical companies. Often the patients receiving these prescriptions are adolescents or children - populations on which these drugs have not been well tested.

Amazingly, these physicians think that this massive conflict of interest can be dismissed simply by denial. According to the NY Times:

"Doctors... maintain that payments from drug companies do not influence what they prescribe for patients."

Yeah, right.

Even without any malicious intent, a conflict of interest can exert an influence on someone's behavior. The NY Times quotes Dr. Steven Hyman, the provost at Harvard:

"There’s an irony that psychiatrists ask patients to have insights into themselves, but we don’t connect the wires in our own lives about how money is affecting our profession and putting our patients at risk."

If a drug works well for a certain class of patients, it should be promoted by physicians who give lectures because they are leaders in their field, not because they have been selected by marketing executives to push the drug. These physicians should show some integrity and not accept lecture fees or other honoraria from drug makers.

No matter how fervently these physicians believe that their professional judgment is not affected, at the very least they should care about maintaining the trust of their patients. Would you be concerned if your child's physician was being paid thousands of dollars to promote an anti-psychotic drug, not officially approved for use in children, that had just been prescribed for your child? I sure as hell would.

Saturday, May 05, 2007

Darwin Among Republican Presidential Contenders

One third of the Republican presidential candidates, when asked in their recent debate whether they believed evolution, admitted that they don't buy it. The blogosphere has already said much about this, and today the NY Times picks up the story.

The NY Times includes this appalling quote by Larry Arnhart, a poli sci professor at Northern Illinois University:

"The intellectual vitality of conservatism in the 21st century will depend on the success of conservatives in appealing to advances in the biology of human nature as confirming conservative thought."

How convenient when science can confirm one's preconceived notions! That's exactly the opposite approach an intellectually honest person (not to mention someone who calls himself a scholar) should be taking, and it's not helpful for the intellectual vitality of any movement that embraces such an outlook.

This whole debate - whether evolution (not 'Darwinism' - evolution is much more than Darwinism) supports conservative thought - brings to mind something Richard Feynman said when discussing the philosophical implications of the Uncertainty Principle:

“In any case that I have ever seen of any of the philosophical ideas of the sciences dragged out into another field, it's completely distorted, a trivial shadow of its original idea, and it seems in some respects to be quite silly..." - and quite wrong, I should add.

(Feynman quote is from the audio recording of Feynman's second lecture on quantum mechanics in his Lectures on Physics.)

Saturday, April 28, 2007

Are boring science classes the reason we aren't training enough American scientists?

Tom Friedman, in his Friday's NY Times column (subscription required) comments on Walter Isaacson's new biography of Einstein and asks:

"If Einstein were alive today and learned science the boring way it is taught in so many U.S. schools, wouldn’t he have ended up at a Wall Street hedge fund rather than developing theories of relativity for a Nobel Prize?"

While our schools can undoubtedly use improvement in their science curricula, there is a more important reason we're not training as many scientists in this country as we should - science just doesn't pay off, at least not until the scientist has reached an age when most other professionals in the US are thinking about how much to put in their 401Ks instead of worrying about where to find their first job. If Einstein were alive today, he'd have good reason for choosing to work at that hedge fund over the spartan life of a young scientist struggling to get a tenure-track job.

By the time you start making a reasonable salary as a scientist, you've watched for years as all your friends who are MBA graduates, computer engineers, physicians, lawyers, or even moderately paid teachers buy houses, take family vacations, buy their kids music, sports, and dance lessons, and start a substantial retirement savings - all while you were just barely getting by from paycheck to paycheck. Scientists begin saving for retirement and their kids' education at an age which financial self-help books tend describe, with half-hearted optimism, in phrases like 'not completely hopeless.'

For a science career, you live in poverty for 5-7 years of grad school, with no retirement benefits and poor health insurance. That's somewhat understandable - law students and med students also live in poverty during their graduate training (although a PhD program is longer, and senior science grad students are already working at a professional level that lawyers and physicians don't reach until after they graduate).

After grad school, a postdoctoral fellowship is absolutely necessary for any kind of academic career at a research university or in a senior position as an industrial scientist - in other words, the kind of permanent job that induces people to seek a PhD in the first place. Postdoctoral fellowships usually run at least three years now, with a salary in the 32-45k range (you maybe reach 45k after 2-3 years, if you have an outside source of funding). As in grad school, there are no 401Ks or other retirement benefits, and even when you do get decent health insurance, all the money for the premiums (including the 'employer' contribution) is considered taxable income through some perverted loophole in the tax code.

Scientists tend to be in their mid- to late 30's by the time they get a permanent job, and on average they don't get their first research grant (critical for establishing an independent research program) until age 42. This is extremely late for people who want at least some financial security before they start a family. Women scientists are disproportionately affected, because the brunt of the work of having children, biologically and usually socially, falls on women. Those who hope to have a family life are faced with the unpleasant choice of waiting a long time or risking their job and financial security to have children at a more normal age.

The whole process can be extremely discouraging and demoralizing. I have a PhD, more than 8 years of experience in the lab, several published papers, my own funding based on a successful, peer-reviewed fellowship proposal, and I earn less than my younger sister, a clothing store manager who successfully worked up from an entry level job in the two years she's been out of college. I work nights and weekends with no overtime pay. Instead of recording overtime, I fill out a time sheet at the end of the month stating my "hours absent" from the university. I have school debt that's accumulating interest, while my kids rely on grandparents to buy them shoes and swimming lessons.

The National Postdoctoral Association
puts it this way:

"Postdoctoral scientists have slipped between the cracks of the scientific workforce as a heterogeneous group of 'apprentice' scientists. They generally do not have well-defined expectations of employment, appropriate employment rights and responsibilities, commensurate or even normalized pay scales, performance evaluations, consistent employment benefits such as proper health care, pensions, occupational health insurance, or procedures for resolving conflict."

We could have the best public school science curricula in the world, but that would not be enough to overcome the large disincentives students face when considering a career in science.